Baby Loss Awareness Week: The heartbreak of Lisa and Ryan

Lisa Buttery (36) and fiancé Ryan Barnes (37) had always wanted to start a family, but despite years of trying, had never been able to conceive. They eventually found out they were pregnant with baby Isla Grace in November 2021 and were overjoyed to finally become parents.

This would be their first child. They put their wedding planning on hold while they prepared for their new arrival.

“Our little miracle”

The pregnancy went smoothly, and baby Isla was growing well. Lisa was referred to the John Radcliffe Hospital in Oxford, where a plan was made for induction of labour at 42 weeks.

Following induction, Lisa’s labour progressed quickly, but baby Isla soon began to struggle. Concerns were first raised by midwives shortly after Lisa’s waters broke, as CTG’s (fetal monitoring equipment) suggested that Isla Grace was getting a limited supply of oxygen during labour. A plan was made to transfer Lisa to the delivery suite, but no beds were available at the time.

In the hours that followed, further concerns were raised by midwives, who felt that Isla’s heart rate was fluctuating dangerously. On three separate occasions, recommendations by the midwives to escalate Lisa to an emergency caesarean section were overruled. Eventually, Lisa was taken for a category two emergency caesarean section. A category two caesarean section is initiated where there is fetal or maternal compromise which is not considered life-threatening. Despite attempts at resuscitation, Isla tragically died at just 19 minutes old.

A coroner’s inquest took place in March 2023, which concluded that Isla died from hypoxic brain damage, signs of which were seen on electronic foetal monitoring (CTG recording).

The process

Tees were approached by Lisa and Ryan, to help guide them through the inquest process and to bring a claim for compensation on behalf of Isla Grace.

Following initial investigations, Tees were able to secure a response from the hospital, who admit that they failed to refer Lisa for an emergency caesarean section once concerns were raised around Isla’s wellbeing. They admit that, had Lisa been sent for an earlier caesarean section, then Isla would likely have survived.

A word from Lisa and Ryan

“Losing our beautiful daughter Isla Grace has forever changed us as people – it is a story we never thought imaginable, let alone something we will now have to live with for the rest of our lives. And that is exactly what it is – a life-long heart break knowing you will never feel true joy again without our first and only child in this world.

We contacted Tees to find answers and justice for Isla as both internal and external investigations didn’t reveal an underlying cause of death. We see that the only benefit that can come from this is change – change to processes, change to assumptions, change to maternity care that we hope will save the lives of thousands of babies – and our hope is that that will be Isla Grace’s legacy.”

Thank you to Lisa and Ryan for giving Tees permission to share their story on Baby Loss Awareness Week, in memory of Isla Grace.

If you are concerned about the care you or your baby received, you can talk to one of our specialists. We’ll listen to your experience and help you get to the truth of what happened.